November 16, 2026. A jury’s verdict is not always the end of a case. The Ventura County Star reported on November 16, 2026 that former Major League Baseball pitcher Scott Erickson has asked a California judge for a new trial on damages in the wrongful death lawsuit over the deaths of Mark Iskander, 11, and Jacob Iskander, 8, who were killed in a Westlake Village, California crosswalk on September 29, 2020. A civil jury in Van Nuys earlier this year found both Erickson and Rebecca Grossman to blame in the boys’ deaths and awarded the Iskander family $176 million in compensatory damages, followed by an additional $22 million in punitive damages, including $1.17 million against Erickson. This report concerns other parties’ case. It is not a Tacher Law case, and Tacher Law did not represent any party in it.
What happened, and the criminal case
According to the Star’s reporting, the boys were crossing Triunfo Canyon Road with their mother and younger brother when they were struck. Grossman, a co-founder of the Grossman Burn Foundation, and Erickson were driving separate vehicles toward her home that evening. Grossman was convicted in 2024 of second-degree murder and other charges arising from the crash and was sentenced to 15 years to life on each of two murder counts and three years for hit-and-run driving, all to run concurrently. The civil lawsuit is separate from that criminal case: the Iskander family sued both Grossman and Erickson for wrongful death, and the civil jury found both of them at fault even though, according to witnesses and Erickson himself, Erickson’s vehicle passed through the crosswalk without striking the boys.
The motion: liability accepted, damages challenged
In a motion filed last month, Erickson’s attorneys asked the judge for a new trial. The motion does not contest liability — Erickson acknowledges the jury found he shared responsibility for the boys’ deaths. What it challenges is the size of the award. His attorneys describe the compensatory damages as excessive and unprecedented, argue the award would leave Erickson destitute many times over, and contend the case was one where, in the motion’s words, “passion and prejudice” naturally run high and the family’s closing argument fanned those flames. Erickson has also asked the judge to cancel all punitive damages against him, arguing the compensatory award alone wipes him out and leaves him unable to pay any punitive amount. A hearing on the motion is scheduled for later this month.
The family’s response
The Iskander family’s attorneys have asked the court to deny the motion. One of the family’s lawyers, Andrew Owen, wrote that a large verdict alone does not compel a conclusion that the award came from passion or prejudice. “Every indicator here points the other way: unrebutted evidence of harm, careful instructions, and a jury that reviewed every side’s numbers and adopted none of them,” Owen wrote. The family argues the verdict compensates three plaintiffs — including the boys’ mother and brother, who were nearly killed themselves and witnessed the aftermath — and that, on punitive damages, the jury heard substantial evidence of Erickson’s financial condition and applied the ability-to-pay instruction that Erickson himself requested. The judge has not yet ruled.
The lesson: a verdict is a milestone, not the finish line
This is a California case, decided under California law — it is not a Florida case. The general lesson travels, and the Florida comparison is offered as a comparison only. In both systems, the losing side can ask the trial judge for a new trial or a reduction of an excessive verdict, and an appeals court can review the result afterward; a verdict becomes final only when those steps are exhausted or the deadlines to take them pass. Size alone is rarely enough to undo a verdict — the moving party generally must show the jury acted from passion or prejudice, or that the award finds no support in the evidence. Punitive damages are a separate phase with their own rules, and a defendant’s ability to pay is part of that analysis. For families in Florida, two practical points matter from day one: wrongful death claims are generally subject to a two-year filing deadline, and the evidence that sustains a verdict — records, witnesses, and documentation of the loss — must be preserved from the start, because it may have to be defended long after the jury speaks.
Disclaimer: This post reports on cases and events involving other parties. Past results in other cases do not guarantee a similar outcome in any future case. This post is general information, not legal advice about any specific situation.
Tacher Law
16445 Collins Avenue, Suite 1625, Sunny Isles Beach, FL 33160
Call +1 (305) 644-2211 for a free consultation, or contact us online.



Leave A Comment