November 17, 2026. A settlement reached in the middle of a trial is not a verdict — and it is not a finding that a product caused an injury. Reuters, reported by Insurance Journal on November 17, 2026, said four women who allege they were diagnosed with cancer as a result of chemical hair straightening products reached a settlement on November 16 with L’Oréal’s U.S. subsidiary and other companies during a trial in Chicago, according to the women’s attorneys. The cases were the first hair relaxer cases to go to trial, and they settled for a confidential sum. This report concerns other parties’ case. It is not a Tacher Law case, and Tacher Law did not represent any party in it.
What the women allege
The women are among thousands who have sued the companies, alleging that years of using chemical hair straighteners caused them to develop gynecologic cancers. The four women — MaryAnne Lindsey, Surenthia Jenkins, Miranda Lofton and Sandra Simpson — sued L’Oréal’s U.S. subsidiary and several other makers of the products in Cook County, Illinois, in 2023 and 2024. Their trial began on November 9 with jury selection. The products at issue have been marketed under names including Dark and Lovely and Optimum, promise to permanently straighten textured hair, and have been widely marketed to Black women. In a statement, Danielle Ward Mason, an attorney for the women, said she hoped the settlement would give the women a sense of justice. These are allegations that were being tested at trial; the settlement ends these four cases without a jury deciding them.
The company’s response
A spokesperson for L’Oréal said the company’s highest priority is the health and wellbeing of its consumers, and that it remains confident in the safety of its SoftSheen-Carson brand hair products, which include hair relaxers. “L’Oréal USA strictly follows all regulations in every market in which it operates, and its products are always subject to a rigorous scientific evaluation of their safety,” the spokesperson said. L’Oréal has also said the study that prompted the first lawsuits did not establish a causal link between the use of the products and any conditions alleged by the plaintiffs. That study, released in 2022 by the National Institutes of Health, found women who used the products several times a year were more than twice as likely to develop uterine cancer. A settlement is a compromise to end a case — it is not an admission of liability, and no court has made a finding in these four cases that the products caused cancer.
Thousands of cases remain
While some cases have been filed in state court, more than 12,700 cases over the same claims are centralized before a judge in federal court in Chicago, court records show. At least two states, Arizona and Minnesota, also sued L’Oréal over the products this year, alleging that the company had misled women about their safety — allegations the company disputes through its safety statements above. The confidential settlement of the first four trial cases does not resolve those thousands of remaining cases, and it does not set a value for any other person’s claim.
The lesson: in a product case, the product and the records are the case
This is an Illinois case, in state and federal courts in Chicago — it is not a Florida case, and Illinois law is not Florida law. The general product-liability principle travels, and the Florida comparison is offered as a comparison only. A person who believes a product injured them generally must be able to show what product they used, when and how often they used it, what injury followed, and what the maker knew and warned about. That is why the practical steps matter from day one: keep the product, its packaging and any receipts; save medical records and write down a timeline of use and symptoms while it is fresh; and do not assume a headline settlement in someone else’s case proves or values yours. Filing deadlines apply in Florida as elsewhere, and they can bar a claim entirely if they pass, so an early review of the facts matters. A confidential, mid-trial settlement also carries a quieter lesson: even the first cases to reach a jury can end without a verdict, so a claim should be built on its own evidence, not on what happened in another courtroom.
Disclaimer: This post reports on cases and events involving other parties. Past results in other cases do not guarantee a similar outcome in any future case. This post is general information, not legal advice about any specific situation.
Tacher Law
16445 Collins Avenue, Suite 1625, Sunny Isles Beach, FL 33160
Call +1 (305) 644-2211 for a free consultation, or contact us online.



Leave A Comment